Metaphors

Do Metaphors Use Like or As? A Clear Answer

Comestible rose in the Laquenexy orchard garden, Moselle, France, image for do metaphors use like or as
Photo: M0tty, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Do metaphors use like or as? Short answer: no. Metaphors do not use “like” or “as.” That’s the main thing that separates them from similes. A simile says one thing is like another. A metaphor just says it is the other thing. “Her eyes were like stars” is a simile; “her eyes were stars” is a metaphor.

That rule works about ninety percent of the time. The other ten percent is where quizzes, essays and arguments happen, so let’s go through it.

Cirrus uncinus clouds in the morning sky, image for do metaphors use like or as
Photo: ADARSHluck, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

The Rule and Why It Exists

“Like” and “as” are comparison words. They announce, “I’m about to compare two things, and I know they’re different.” A simile is honest about that. A metaphor drops the announcement and speaks as though the two were one, which is why it often hits harder.

Wordsworth wrote “I wandered lonely as a cloud,” a famous simile with its “as” right out in front. Robert Burns wrote “O my Luve is like a red, red rose,” another. Now compare Dickinson’s “Hope is the thing with feathers,” where no flag word appears. Same poet’s trick, different volume. Read all three aloud and you’ll feel the difference: the simile has a small step in it, the metaphor doesn’t.

Trickier Cases Where “Like” or “As” Appears

When “like” isn’t comparing

“I like pizza” has the word, but nothing is being compared. Same with “as” in “she works as a nurse.” There, “as” means “in the role of.” It’s a plain statement of fact, so neither a simile nor a metaphor.

When “as” begins a time clause

“As the sun set, the street emptied” is just timing. Don’t circle it.

When the word is there but the comparison is hidden

“He eats like a horse” is a simile and the meaning is easy: he eats a lot. “He’s a horse at the table” is the metaphor version. Look for the construction, not the letters.

“As if” and “as though”

These phrases signal a comparison too: “The house stood as if it were waiting.” Most teachers treat this as simile-like. Some call it a metaphor because the house “waits,” which is a human act. Honestly, this one splits readers. If your teacher has a view, follow it.

Fallen tree in greece, image for do metaphors use like or as

Do Metaphors Use Like or As in Any Form? Quick Checks

Use these three when you’re stuck.

  1. Look for a direct “is” or “was” joining two different things. “Her eyes were stars” has one. That’s a metaphor.
  2. Look for “like” or “as” that sits between the two things. “Her eyes were like stars” has it. That’s a simile.
  3. If neither is there, check the verb. “The wind howled” has no flag, but “howled” borrows from an animal. Implied metaphor.

One handy trick for turning a simile into a metaphor: delete the flag word and fix the grammar. “He runs like a deer” becomes “He is a deer on the track.” The meaning barely moves, but the tone does. It gets bolder and a bit more theatrical.

Why So Many Students Mix Them Up

Partly because the two feel the same. If you say “my room is a pigsty” or “my room is like a pigsty,” your listener understands both instantly, and in daily talk nobody cares which is which. The labels only matter in school and in analysis.

Partly because textbooks teach the flag-word rule so loudly that students stop looking at anything else. Then a sentence like “She works as a teacher” gets circled for no reason. My advice: find the comparison first, the flag word second. If nothing is being compared, there’s nothing to label.

Which One Should You Use When Writing?

A simile gives the reader a bit of distance, so it suits comparisons that are fresh or slightly odd. “The meeting dragged like a Monday” is gentle and funny. A metaphor suits moments of strong feeling or confidence. “The meeting was a funeral” tells the reader how you felt right away.

Don’t treat one as better. A page of nothing but metaphors can feel overheated, and a page of similes can sound hesitant. Mix them. If you want to see which suits a topic, compare our similes for ocean with our metaphors for stars and notice how the tone shifts.

Wikipedia has a tidy overview of metaphor and the dictionary-style comparison at Oxford Learner’s Dictionaries lists the simile alongside it.

A Short Practice Round

Label each one: simile, metaphor or neither.

  • The baby slept like a log.
  • The baby is an angel.
  • The baby slept as the rain fell.
  • The baby’s laugh rang through the house.

Answers: simile; metaphor; neither (it’s about time); metaphor, since a laugh “rang” like a bell. If you got three, you’re doing fine. For more practice with imaginative figures, see similes for reading, then swap the “like” lines into “is” lines yourself.

Frequently Asked Questions

So do metaphors use like or as, ever?

By definition, no. If a sentence uses “like” or “as” to compare, it’s a simile. Some writers use “as if” in a loose way, which is why the border is fuzzy.

Is “like a rock” a metaphor?

No, it’s a simile. “He is a rock” is the metaphor.

Can a sentence have both?

Yes. “Her voice was honey, warm as a summer afternoon” holds a metaphor and a simile together.

Which is older?

Both go back to ancient writing. Greek and Roman writers discussed both, and the tricks are far older than the terms for them.

Jason Downs

Hey there! I'm Mr. Downs, an English teacher and Department Chair at Kory Hunter Middle School. I'm also an AI Classroom Innovator! I'm passionate about language and love exploring fun phrases and words. Lets explore some out of this world Idioms, Similies, Phase and Metaphor together. We'll learn lots of cool stuff and have a blast doing it!