Metaphors

Visual Metaphors in Design, Ads and Film

Billboard in Menands, New York, image for visual metaphors
Photo: Tyler A. McNeil, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Quick test. Is the arrow hidden between the E and the x in the FedEx logo a visual metaphor? Many people say yes. It’s actually a clever piece of negative space: a shape tucked into the gap between two letters, suggesting speed and direction. Clever, but a hidden shape is not the same as a metaphor. Visual metaphors are something else, and knowing the difference makes you a sharper reader of every poster, film and app icon you see.

What Makes an Image a Visual Metaphor

A verbal metaphor says “time is a thief.” A visual metaphor shows it. The picture presents one thing so that you understand another: a clock with a burglar’s mask, say. Two conditions have to be true. The image must stand for something other than what it literally shows, and the viewer must be able to work out the link.

That second condition is where most failures happen. If a design needs a caption to explain it, it is probably a symbol the audience hasn’t learned yet, or just a bad image.

Metaphor versus symbol versus sign

A symbol (a dove for peace) is agreed by custom. A sign (a red octagon) works by rule. A visual metaphor makes a fresh comparison on the spot. In practice these blur together, and designers mix them all the time. Don’t worry about neat boxes. Ask yourself whether the picture is asking you to see A as B.

Adapted Lens on Mirrorless Camera, image for visual metaphors

Real Examples You Already Know

ExampleWhat it showsWhat it means
“Join, or Die” (1754)A snake cut into piecesThe colonies must unite
Desktop, folder and trash iconsOffice objects on a screenFiles and commands on a computer
Amazon logoArrow from A to Z, shaped like a smileEverything for sale, happy customers
Modern Times (1936)Sheep, then workersWorkers herded like animals
Dali’s melting clocksSoft, drooping watchesTime that bends in dreams and memory

A few of these deserve a closer look.

The snake that tried to unite a continent

Benjamin Franklin published the “Join, or Die” cartoon in his Pennsylvania Gazette in 1754. A snake is cut into sections, each labeled with a colony or region. There’s an old belief that a severed snake could come back to life if the pieces were joined. Whether or not people trusted that, the idea landed: united you live, divided you die. It is widely treated as one of the first political cartoons in the American colonies, and the Wikipedia article on Join, or Die has the history.

The desktop on your screen

Your computer does not contain a desktop, a folder or a trash can. Those are visual metaphors, borrowed from the office and made popular by Xerox and Apple in the early 1980s. People who had never seen a command line could look at a little paper folder and guess what it did. Read more in the overview of the desktop metaphor. It is probably the most-used visual metaphor in history, and we hardly notice it.

Visual Metaphors in Film

Cinema has a special tool: the edit. Put two shots next to each other and the audience makes the comparison without being told.

  • Charlie Chaplin, Modern Times (1936). The film opens on a flock of sheep, then cuts to workers pouring out of a subway station. Nobody says “people are sheep.” The edit does.
  • Sergei Eisenstein, Strike (1925). Footage of a bull being slaughtered is intercut with soldiers attacking striking workers. The violence of one explains the other.
  • Stanley Kubrick, 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968). An ape throws a bone into the air and the film cuts to a spacecraft. Tool to technology, millions of years in one cut.

Honestly, the sheep still gets me. It is so simple and so rude.

Palette en plein air, image for visual metaphors

Advertising and Design

Ads have a few seconds, so they rely on pictures the viewer already understands. Apple’s “1984” commercial for the Macintosh, shown during the Super Bowl in January 1984, is a famous case. A runner hurls a hammer at a giant screen full of a droning leader, in a setting borrowed from Orwell’s novel. Most viewers read it as conformity being smashed. The product barely appears.

On a smaller scale, think of the lightbulb that means “idea”, the padlock for security, or a battery icon for energy. Those are so worn they have almost turned into symbols. Fresh ones are rare, and that’s why good ones get noticed.

Photography

Photographers work with framing. A single red umbrella in a crowd of black ones becomes “the one who stands out.” A tiny figure under a huge sky becomes “feeling small.” The idea is not in the photograph; it is in the way you are invited to read it.

Using Visual Metaphors Well

Three rules I keep returning to. Pick one idea per image. Choose a picture your audience will recognize, since a metaphor that needs a footnote has failed. And test it on someone who has not seen the brief. If they say something close to what you meant, you’re done. If they say something else, listen to them.

The same thinking helps language learners, which is why our pieces on turning idioms into visual scenes and visual learning and idioms are worth a look. For written pairs, try our list of metaphors about art, or see how brands do it in the visual idioms of perfume packaging.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a visual metaphor in simple terms?

It is an image that shows one thing so you understand another. A snake cut into pieces stands for divided colonies. The viewer makes the leap.

Is a logo a visual metaphor?

Sometimes. The Amazon arrow, for example, links A to Z and forms a smile. Many logos are only symbols or clever shapes, such as the arrow hidden in the FedEx wordmark, which is a negative-space trick rather than a metaphor.

What is the difference between visual metaphors and symbols?

A symbol has a fixed, learned meaning. A visual metaphor builds a new comparison in front of you. A dove is a symbol; a dove made of barbed wire is a metaphor.

Where can I see good visual metaphors?

Editorial cartoons, magazine covers, film editing, poster design and user interface icons. Start with your own phone screen.

Jason Downs

Hey there! I'm Mr. Downs, an English teacher and Department Chair at Kory Hunter Middle School. I'm also an AI Classroom Innovator! I'm passionate about language and love exploring fun phrases and words. Lets explore some out of this world Idioms, Similies, Phase and Metaphor together. We'll learn lots of cool stuff and have a blast doing it!